Stop Wasting Money on Repairs—Upgrade to a Reliable New AC

When your air conditioner is beyond repair or simply not worth the cost to fix, an air conditioning replacement is the right solution. And when that time comes, you need a trustworthy contractor who will handle the process from start to finish with transparency, professionalism, and care. That’s exactly what you’ll find with T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

Our air conditioning replacement services in Garrett, IN, take the stress out of this big decision while providing you with a reliable cooling system that’s built to last. T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc. is here to guide you through your options, offer competitive pricing, and install a system you can depend on during Indiana’s hottest months.

Need a New AC? Choose the Experts Garrett Homeowners Rely On

Replacing an air conditioner is a major investment, and choosing the right contractor matters just as much as selecting the right equipment. For decades, T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc. has been helping homeowners in Garrett, DeKalb County, and surrounding areas enjoy dependable home comfort with high-quality air conditioning replacement services.
We pride ourselves on:

  • Clear, upfront pricing with no surprise charges
  • Expert recommendations that consider your home size, cooling needs, and budget
  • Skilled technicians who treat your home with respect
  • Trusted brands and energy-efficient systems to lower your cooling costs
  • Fast, professional installation so you’re not left sweltering in the summer heat


From the Garrett Historic District to neighborhoods near Garrett High School, our team is known for delivering exceptional service and lasting results.

Financing Your Air Conditioning Replacement

Air conditioning replacement is not always something you can plan for. To help make your air conditioning replacement more affordable, we offer convenient financing with approved credit. Our team can walk you through available options so you can get the cooling you need now without breaking your budget.

How to Know When It’s Time for an Air Conditioning Replacement

If you’ve been told your AC is no longer worth repairing or it’s completely stopped working, you’re already halfway to making a decision. But if you’re still on the fence, here are the most common signs that it’s time to replace your system rather than repair it.

Frequent Repairs Are Draining Your Budget

If you’ve called for air conditioning repair more than once or twice in the past couple of years, the costs can start adding up fast. While the occasional repair is normal, repeated service calls often mean your system is failing in multiple areas. At that point, putting money toward a new air conditioning replacement is typically a smarter investment.

Poor Performance and Uneven Cooling

An AC that struggles to keep your home cool or leaves some rooms comfortable while others feel like saunas is likely past its prime. This could be due to worn-out components, airflow issues, or simply an undersized system for your space. Air conditioning installation will provide consistent cooling from your living room to the upstairs bedrooms.

Rising Energy Bills Without Increased Usage

If your utility costs keep climbing but your cooling habits haven’t changed, your air conditioner may be running inefficiently. Older systems often work harder to achieve the same results, which burns more energy and inflates your monthly bill. An energy-efficient air conditioning replacement can help lower those costs, especially during peak summer months in DeKalb County.

An Aging System Past Its Lifespan

Most central cooling systems last about 10–15 years with proper air conditioning maintenance. Once your unit reaches that age range, it’s more susceptible to breakdowns and declining performance. Even if it’s still running, you might be losing money through inefficiency. Upgrading now ensures you’ll have a system designed to meet today’s efficiency standards and handle Indiana’s unpredictable heat waves.

Repair Costs That Rival the Price of a New Unit

When repairs cost more than half of what it would take to replace the system, replacement is the better choice. This is especially true if your AC is older or already showing other warning signs. Choosing an air conditioning replacement from T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc. means you’re investing in a fresh start rather than pouring money into a unit that could fail again soon.

Choosing the Right Replacement AC for Your Garrett Home

Not all air conditioners are created equal, and we take the time to help you select the perfect fit. When recommending your air conditioning replacement, we consider:

  • Home Size and Layout: The right size air conditioner will provide even cooling throughout your space
  • Energy Efficiency Ratings (SEER): Choosing a higher efficiency unit can mean lower utility bills
  • Budget: We work within your budget while providing high-quality solutions
  • Special Features: Variable-speed motors, smart thermostats, or enhanced air filtration can improve your living environment.

From compact units for smaller homes to high-capacity systems for larger spaces, we’ll help you find a cooling solution that keeps you comfortable all summer long.

Your Path to Reliable Cooling Starts Here

At T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc., we believe that air conditioning replacement in Garrett, IN, shouldn’t be a guessing game. Our process is designed to be straightforward, transparent, and stress-free:

  1. Initial Consultation and Inspection: We evaluate your current system, confirm your cooling needs, and discuss your goals and budget.
  2. System Recommendations: We present options from trusted brands that are the right size and efficiency for your home.
  3. Upfront Pricing: You’ll know exactly what the replacement will cost—no surprises.
  4. Professional Installation: Our technicians remove your old system, install the new one, and ensure everything is operating perfectly.
  5. Post-Installation Walkthrough: We’ll show you how to operate your new AC and answer all your questions.
  6. Ongoing Support: We’re here for maintenance, repairs, and any future service you might need.


Whether your home is near the Mountz House or closer to the Judy A. Morrill Recreation Center, our installation team arrives on time, works efficiently, and treats your property with the utmost care.

Frequently Asked Questions About Air Conditioning Replacement

The “$5,000 rule” is a simple way to decide if you should repair or replace your HVAC system. You take the age of your unit and multiply it by the cost of the repair. If that number is more than $5,000, replacement is usually the better choice. For example, if your AC is 12 years old and needs a $500 repair, 12 x 500 = $6,000—meaning it’s likely time to invest in a new unit. This rule helps you avoid putting too much money into an older system that may soon need more costly fixes.

Yes—most air conditioners are designed to last 10–15 years. At 20 years old, your AC is far past its expected lifespan and likely costing you more in repairs and energy bills than it should. Even if it’s still running, it’s probably not cooling as efficiently as a modern system. An air conditioning replacement will give you better performance, lower energy costs, and peace of mind that your home will stay comfortable during the hottest days in Garrett, IN.

Homeowners insurance usually covers your AC unit if it’s damaged by a covered event like a storm, fire, or vandalism. However, it won’t cover normal wear and tear, age-related breakdowns, or issues from lack of maintenance. If your unit has failed due to old age or mechanical problems, insurance typically won’t pay for a replacement. That’s why regular maintenance and timely replacement are key to avoiding sudden, out-of-pocket expenses.

A 20-year-old air conditioner can be extremely inefficient compared to today’s systems. Older units often have a Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) of 8–10, while modern systems are required to have a SEER rating of at least 14, and many go much higher. That means your old AC could be using 30–50% more energy to produce the same cooling. Over the course of a hot Indiana summer, that inefficiency can translate into hundreds of extra dollars on your utility bills.

Absolutely. A properly sized, modern AC will not only cool your home more evenly, but it can also improve humidity control and indoor air quality. If your current system struggles to keep up, especially in upstairs rooms or areas far from the thermostat, an air conditioning replacement can make a noticeable difference. T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc. will help you choose a system that’s perfectly matched to your home, so you get reliable, efficient comfort all summer long.

Get an Estimate for Garrett, IN Air Conditioning Replacement Today

If your AC has stopped working and can’t be repaired or if you’re tired of sinking money into an aging unit, it’s time to call the local experts you can trust. T&T Plumbing & Heating, Inc. is ready to provide the professional air conditioning replacement service you need to restore comfort to your home.

Contact us today to schedule your consultation and get a free, no-obligation estimate. We proudly serve Garrett, IN, DeKalb County, and surrounding areas with dependable cooling solutions that stand the test of time.

T&T Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning & Geothermal Logo